AgencyKey vs Supercreator (2026)
AgencyKey keeps people in the chat and includes its AI tools in the price. Supercreator is built around Izzy, an AI chatter that sends on its own for a fee plus 5% of AI sales.
By OnlyFans CRM team · Updated · Sources
Quick verdict
AgencyKey is the better CRM for human chat teams: $10–$35 per creator for accounts under $5,000 net, with no cut of sales. Supercreator is the pick if you want an AI to run chats, from $99 per account plus 5% of AI sales.
Choose AgencyKey if…
From $10/mo · #1 on the board (88.4)
your chatters do the selling and you want a cheaper, more detailed team workspace, with AI that summarizes and researches fans but never messages them.
Read the AgencyKey review
Choose Supercreator if…
Free Lite; Premium from $15/mo · #3 on the board (81.1)
you want an AI to carry conversations, price PPVs and hand hot chats to a person, or you want to start free on Lite with up to 10 accounts.
Read the Supercreator reviewAgencyKey vs Supercreator side by side
| Attribute | AgencyKey | Supercreator |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 88.4 (#1) | 81.1 (#3) |
| Best for | OnlyFans agencies with human chat teams that want low per-creator pricing | Agencies and creators that want AI to run chats, inside a full CRM |
| Starting price | From $10/mo | Free Lite; Premium from $15/mo |
| How you pay | Per creator, by net earnings (10 bands) | Per account by 30-day earnings; AI adds 5% of sales |
| Platforms | OnlyFans | OnlyFans |
| AI | Summaries, fan recon and admin agent; no auto-replies | Autonomous Izzy with handoff; Premium copilot |
| Free trial | 30 active days, no card | 14 days, no card |
| App | Desktop app (Windows, macOS) plus web | Desktop (Mac, Windows), mobile, extension |
Entry prices cover the lowest band, not a whole roster. Put your real accounts into the cost calculator.
What 10 creators cost on each
Two creators at each of $400, $1,800, $4,500, $8,000, $14,000 gross a month. Subscription only, before AI commissions, add-ons and tax. AgencyKey bills on net earnings (80% of gross after OnlyFans' fee) and Infloww on gross; the other vendors don't say, so every creator here sits in the same band either way.
- AgencyKey#1 overall
All features
$440 /mo Premium
$582 /mo
Prices from each vendor's public pricing page. A cheaper plan does not mean the same features: compare the reviews before you switch. Price your own roster.
AgencyKey pricing
| Plan or band | Price |
|---|---|
| $0–$1,000 net earnings | $10/mo |
| $1,000–$3,000 | $25/mo |
| $3,000–$5,000 | $35/mo |
| $5,000–$7,500 | $50/mo |
| $7,500–$10,000 | $75/mo |
| $10,000–$15,000 | $100/mo |
| $15,000–$25,000 | $125/mo |
| $25,000–$35,000 | $150/mo |
| $35,000–$50,000 | $200/mo |
| $50,000+ | $250/mo |
Supercreator pricing
| Plan or band | Price |
|---|---|
| Lite | Free |
| Under $1,000 earnings | Premium $15 · Super AI $99 |
| $1,000–$15,000 | Premium $69 · Super AI $119 |
| $15,000–$25,000 | Premium $149 · Super AI $199 |
| Over $25,000 | Premium $249 · Super AI $299 |
The differences that decide it
Who sends the messages
Supercreator's Izzy chats on its own, prices PPVs and hands hot fans to a chatter. AgencyKey's AI only helps the chatter. Reuters reported in 2024 that OnlyFans' terms barred AI chatbots from writing DMs, which matters for the autonomous route.
Price without AI
Supercreator Premium is $15 per account under $1,000 of earnings and $69 from $1,000 to $15,000. AgencyKey charges $10 to $100 across the same range on net earnings. For our 10-creator example: AgencyKey $440, Supercreator Premium $582.
Price with AI
Super AI is $99 to $299 per account plus 5% of AI net sales, with 2,000 to 6,000 AI messages included. AgencyKey's AI tools carry no extra fee or commission.
Free options
Supercreator Lite is free for up to 10 accounts but can't be mixed with paid plans. AgencyKey's trial gives each creator up to 30 active days with no card.
One task to run in both trials
Run the same creator for a week: AgencyKey with your chatters, Supercreator with Izzy reviewed before sending. Compare sales, corrections and the full bill including Supercreator's 5%.
Download the worksheet to record what you find.
More comparisons
AgencyKey vs Supercreator: FAQ
Which is cheaper, AgencyKey or Supercreator?
AgencyKey starts at From $10/mo (per creator, by net earnings (10 bands)). Supercreator starts at Free Lite; Premium from $15/mo (per account by 30-day earnings; ai adds 5% of sales). Entry prices cover the lowest band, so price every account at its own earnings level before comparing totals.
Do AgencyKey and Supercreator support Fansly or Fanvue?
AgencyKey: OnlyFans. Supercreator: OnlyFans.
Which scores higher on our board?
AgencyKey ranks higher: AgencyKey is #1 with 88.4/100 and Supercreator is #3 with 81.1/100 in the October 2026 edition. The overall score weights chatting, AI, analytics, agency tools, pricing and reliability.
Sources and verification
These are the vendor pages used for the product facts on this page. Listed features and vendor claims have not been independently benchmarked on live creator accounts.
- AgencyKey pricing calculator· Checked
Ten net-earnings bands from $10 to $250 per creator, inclusions and the no-card trial.
- AgencyKey billing guide· Checked
30-day net-earnings basis, renewal, prepaid balance, payment methods, grace period and trial rules.
- AgencyKey chat interface guide· Checked
Per-creator tabs, filters, pinned chats and the desktop workspace. Documentation, not a speed benchmark.
- AgencyKey Smart Lists guide· Checked
Dynamic fan filters, sync to native OnlyFans lists and the 10,000-fan sync limit.
- AgencyKey roles and permissions· Checked
Permission tree and data scope by agency, group or own data.
- AgencyKey creator analytics· Checked
Revenue, cohort LTV, fan funnel, tracking-link ROI, CSV export and shared reports.
- AgencyKey AI Recon and Chat Summary· Checked
Fan briefings from cross-creator chat history and their limits; Chat Summary is documented alongside.
- AgencyKey AI agent and MCP connector· Checked
Built-in agent, Claude and ChatGPT connector, supported actions and stated limits.
- AgencyKey data sharing settings· Checked
Cross-agency fan data sharing is on by default for AI Recon and Platform Stats; per-creator opt-out.
- AgencyKey data migration guide· Checked
CSV and archive import and export; media files, employees and roles are not transferred.
- AgencyKey changelog, September 2026· Checked
101 entries in September 2026; 94 in August and 19 in October through the 18th.
- AgencyKey comparison page· Checked
Vendor roadmap notes (Fansly and AI reply suggestions listed as coming soon) and migration help. Its competitor prices are vendor-published and not used here.
- Supercreator pricing· Checked
Lite, Premium and Super AI by 30-day earnings tier; included AI messages; per-account licensing.
- Supercreator pricing FAQ· Checked
Earnings-based tiers, refunds and platform scope.
- Supercreator AI pricing· Checked
5% of Izzy's net sales after OnlyFans' cut, messages by tier and $0.03 extra messages (July 28, 2026).
- Supercreator AI Chatter (Izzy)· Checked
Autopilot, handoff, guardrails and vendor claims.